METR - Development Approach

Systems engineering based on stakeholder engagement to illicit user needs

Overview

To facilitate input from stakeholders, ISO/TC 204/WG 19 hosted a series of public workshops in late 2021. The results of these workshops led to the development of the Operational Concept (ConOps), including the user needs and constraints. The draft of this document was developed within ISO/TC 204/WG 19 and a Committee Draft (CD) was released for committee consultation on 7 June 2022. Based on the comments received from this review period, the terms and definition contained within the draft were separated into a separate Part 1 Vocabulary document making the ConOps Part 2. In July 2023, a second draft of the ConOps was released along with a draft of the Vocabulary and a complete System of Systems Requirements and Architecture (SoSR) document. The SoSR defines the requirements for the entire METR network that fulfil the user needs and constraints of the ConOps. The SoSR also explains the architecture for the METR network consists of several systems that are separately managed forming a system of systems (SoS). These systems include the (1) regulation system, (2) distribution system, (3) consumer system, and (4) discrepancy handling system.

Future parts of the standard will specify how the SoSR requirements are realized by the component systems within METR and thereby how these components fulfil the user needs defined in the ConOps. Another future part of the standard will define METR data requirements. Eventually, interface specifications will be developed to define precisely how data will be exchanged to enable interoperability, but it is still unclear if this will be an ISO standard or implemented through regional standards.

Workshop Results

ISO/TC 204/WG 19 held a series of 12 workshops to gain feedback from industry stakeholders. Participants included 47 stakeholders from 13 countries as shown in the pie chart.

We continue to seek input from others during our online development of the ConOps. Several additional meetings have been held since the original workshops to gain additional insights from other stakeholders, especially from stakeholder categories (e.g., lawyers) who were under-represented during the Workshop sessions.

Workshops

The detailed slides and chat logs from the original series of 12 workshops are provided in the table below along with an listing of summary points from all 12 workshops that include traces to the ConOps.

Summary Points  

Date Start Time / Presentation Topic Details
28 Sept Presentation 01 - METR operations
focused on performance needs and constraints, operational modes, and the general process for distribution
Discussion
5 Oct Presentation 02 - METR operational structure
focused on the roles and relationships among stakeholders operating METR
Discussion
12 Oct Presentation 03 - Electronic regulation lifecycle
focused on the needs for electronic regulation creation, activation, and withdrawal
Discussion
19 Oct Presentation 04 - Electronic regulation conflicts
focused on resolution of potential conflicts between physical and electronic regulations or jurisdictional regulations
Discussion
26 Oct Presentation 05 - Vehicle operations
focused on driver assistance and driver automation technologies, and relating electronic information to the physical world
Discussion
2 Nov Presentation 06 - Vehicle information needs
focused on the information needs and expectations of driver assistance and driver automation technologies
Discussion
9 Nov Presentation 07 - Campus governance
focused on authorization, requirements, and responsibilities for universities, shopping centres, hospitals, and similar facilities
Discussion
16 Nov Presentation 08 - Campus regulations
focused on regulatory processes, parking regulations, legality and enforcement for universities, shopping centres, hospitals, and similar facilities
Discussion
23 Nov Presentation 09 - Roadwork and emergency operations
focused on evacuations, weather conditions, and work zones
Discussion
30 Nov Presentation 10 - Multimodal and micromobility operations
focused on ridesourcing, sidewalk delivery devices, and kerbside usage
Discussion
7 Dec Presentation 11 - METR deployment I
focused on regulator participation requirements, conformance levels, responsibilities, and encouraging participants
Discussion
14 Dec Presentation 12 - METR deployment II
focused on needs for the transition to METR, archiving, recovery, and oversight
Discussion

Stakeholders

To better ensure that these standards address both today's and tomorrow's needs, ISO/TC 204/WG 19 continues to seek input from surface transport professionals and advocates to better understand stakeholder needs that should be incorporated into the METR standards. Specifically, ISO/TC 204/WG 19 is interested in hearing from stakeholders representing the following perspectives (recognizing that some stakeholders might fit into multiple perspectives):

  • Regulators
  • Transport users
  • Support providers
  • Third parties